The Long Game: Why Relationship-Driven Recruiters Always Win

In partnership with

Unlock Windsurf Editor, by Codeium.

Introducing the Windsurf Editor, the first agentic IDE. All the features you know and love from Codeium’s extensions plus new capabilities such as Cascade that act as collaborative AI agents, combining the best of copilot and agent systems. This flow state of working with AI creates a step-change in AI capability that results in truly magical moments.

Download It Free Today

Here's the hard truth about agency recruiting:

Anyone can get lucky and make a placement. Anyone can have a hot streak. But building a sustainable, respected recruiting practice? That's a different game entirely.

I've spent years in technical recruiting, placing developers and engineers at companies ranging from startups to Fortune 500s. And I've noticed a clear pattern that separates the elite recruiters from the rest:

The best recruiters prioritize relationships over transactions. Every. Single. Time.

Let me share two recent stories that perfectly illustrate this principle in action.

The Tortoise and the Hare of Recruiting

Let’s get one thing straight: transactional recruiters can succeed. For a while. They make placements, go on hot streaks, and close deals. But eventually, they hit a wall. Why? Because they aren’t building trust. They’re not becoming partners to their clients or candidates; they’re just salespeople.

Relationship-driven recruiters, on the other hand, play the long game. They’re the tortoise to the transactional recruiter’s hare. They take the time to understand their candidates and clients, offer genuine advice, and prioritize what’s best for them—even when it’s not immediately beneficial for the recruiter. That’s how they win. Not just today, but for years to come.

Building Foundational Trust

Here’s the secret sauce: trust. It’s not flashy, it’s not immediate, but it’s the bedrock of every great recruiting relationship. When your candidates trust you, they call you first—not your competitor—when they’re ready to make a move. When your clients trust you, they give you exclusive business, referrals, and introductions. You become more than a recruiter. You become a trusted advisor.

But trust isn’t built by accident. It’s built by actions. By treating candidates like people, not placements. By being honest, transparent, and empathetic. By doing what’s best for them—not what’s best for your commission check.

Let me show you how this works in practice with two real stories

Story #1: The Java Developer Who Came Back Around

Last week, I witnessed firsthand how relationship-building pays off in unexpected ways. A colleague reached out about a Java Developer role at a major financial services firm in New Jersey. While this wasn't one of my primary accounts, I had two strong candidates in my pipeline who fit the bill.

Another recruiter also submitted a candidate, who ultimately received the offer. Now, here's where most recruiters would have ghosted their candidates and moved on. Instead, I immediately reached out to mine:

"I wanted to let you know right away that they've extended an offer to another candidate. I know you're actively searching, and I don't want you to miss any opportunities while waiting on this one."

That transparency built trust. And that trust? It paid dividends just one week later when the other candidate backed out.

Suddenly, my two candidates were back in play. But there was a catch – the hiring manager needed two weeks to make a decision. During this time, both candidates had other interviews lined up. They were transparent with me about this, and I respected their position.

Instead of pressuring them to cancel their other interviews (like many recruiters would), I asked a simple question: "Where does this role rank compared to your other opportunities?"

Both said it was their top choice. My response?

"Go take those other interviews. We'll do everything we can to push for an offer here, but at the end of the day, you have to do what's best for your family. All I ask is that if you receive another offer, just give me a heads up so we can pivot accordingly."

When the offer finally came through, one candidate had another offer pending. But guess what? He chose our offer immediately. Why? Because throughout the process, we treated him like a human being, not a commission check.

Note: I still ABC/Pre-closed them here. The difference in this role and why I was so suggestive was that we had no clue why the manager was taking so long when he said we had the next 2 best candidates. So we didn’t know if he was serious or blowing smoke.

Story #2: The Full-Stack Developer Who Didn’t Give Up

he second story spans several months and showcases the long-term value of relationship building.

Last summer, we were recruiting for a full stack Java developer position at another financial services company. We had an exceptional candidate who came in second place. Instead of simply sending a rejection email, I called her personally.

"I want you to know that this isn't a reflection on you – you interviewed brilliantly. There was simply someone who had a slightly better fit for their specific needs. Let me share some insights about what made the difference, and how you might approach similar situations in the future..."

I spent time giving her detailed feedback and market insights. We discussed interview strategies and how to position herself better in future opportunities. Most recruiters would consider this a waste of time – after all, there's no immediate placement fee to be earned.

Fast forward to this month. The same hiring manager had a new opening for a React developer. We had a candidate in the final round, but then the manager pivoted – they actually needed a full stack developer again.

Remember that candidate from the summer? Because we'd maintained a relationship built on trust and genuine support, she was still interested in the group. One phone call later, we had our solution.

Instead of starting a fresh search and wasting more time, the hiring manager trusted our judgment and hired her immediately. Why? Because we'd proven ourselves as true partners, not just transaction-focused recruiters.

Why Relationships Always Win

These stories have a common thread: trust and relationships. In both cases, the candidates chose to work with me—and my clients—because they felt valued and respected. That’s what happens when you prioritize relationships over transactions.

It’s not just about making placements; it’s about becoming the go-to recruiter for candidates and clients alike. The person they call first. The person they trust to act in their best interests.

Transactional recruiters might win the short game, but relationship-driven recruiters win the marathon.

Action Steps for Building Trust

If you’re ready to become a relationship-driven recruiter, here are three things you can start doing today:

1. Communicate Transparently: Keep your candidates informed every step of the way. Even if the news isn’t what they want to hear, they’ll appreciate your honesty.

2. Give Genuine Advice: Don’t just place candidates; help them navigate their careers. Offer interview tips, market insights, and long-term guidance.

3. Put Their Interests First: If a role isn’t the right fit, tell them. If they’re weighing multiple offers, help them make the best decision for their goals—not yours. They’ll pay you back in referrals, recommendations, you’ll earn good karma, and it’s just the right thing to do.

Closing Thoughts

Recruiting is about people. It’s about building connections, earning trust, and doing what’s right—even when it’s not convenient. That’s how you build a reputation, a network, and a career that stands the test of time.

Play the long game. Treat your candidates like people, not placements. Build relationships, not transactions. Because in the end, the tortoise always wins.